The Difference Between jiu jitsu vs bjj | Pros and cons
Japanese Jiu-Jitsu was one of the earliest martial arts to be formed into a system that could be practiced and taught. It came long before the Brazilian version, which wasn't formed until the early s that a Brazilian family, the Gracies, took the ancient Japanese martial art and modernized it. Today their Brazilian version is taught in schools all over the world and is recognized as one of the most effective forms of self-defense.
The origins of Japanese Jiu-Jitsu are unclear because it formed centuries ago. It's even speculated to have originated in India among Buddhist monks who were looking for a way to peacefully defend themselves. The name Jiu-Jitsu can be roughly translated as the "peaceful way" which means that it's meant to be performed without weapons. However, another school of thought is that the art was developed for samurai soldiers who were unarmed during combat. That means the original form of Jiu-Jitsu was probably much more violent than the one practiced today.
It was likely distilled over the years into an art that could be taught to citizens for sport and recreation, making it much less dangerous. The original version was a mixture of wrestling and other bare-handed techniques that used leverage and friction to defeat an opponent instead of punches and kicks. They also used submissions to hurt their opponents. Japanese Jiu-Jitsu was also much more varied and complex than the Brazilian version taught today.
In the s another form of martial art that incorporated Jiu-Jitsu was formed in Japan, called Judo. It quickly became the official martial art of Japan after it was found to be more effective in combat. One of the members of the Gracie family, a boy named Helio, was physically frail and unable to participate as a boy.
Instead, he watched his brothers teach classes at their family's Jiu-Jitsu gym. One day his older brother showed up to teach a class and Helio stepped in to teach for him. He taught well since he had been memorizing the techniques for years from the sidelines. After that, Helio began creating his own system of Jiu-Jitsu that would work for his weaker physique. He modified the moves from the original Japanese style and created his own, which was eventually dubbed Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu.
He used his style to beat some of the best martial artists in Brazil. He even challenged the Jiu-Jitsu champion of Japan, who was around 80 pounds heavier than Helio, and impressed the champion so much that he was invited to teach in Japan. The Brazilian version of Jiu-Jitsu is much more simplified than the Japanese version, which is most likely why it's so popular. By including fewer techniques in the art, Brazilians are able to concentrate their practice on honing and mastering fewer skills.
It's now a competitive sport with an international championship. In an MMA fight the competitors can use kicks, punches, knees, elbows, takedowns or submissions to defeat an opponent. Brazilian jiu-jitsu lends itself very well to the sport because it's a very effective way to neutralize an opponent, take them down and force them to submit. In fact, Helio Gracie's son, Royce Gracie, was one of the first champions in the biggest mixed martial arts federation in the world, the UFC.BJJ Brazilian Jiu-jitsu is undeniably the most popular grappling system on the planet right now.
There are differences in both the training methods, and in the way that some of the techniques are applied. Every martial art contains different techniques, training methods and training equipment. Of these three factors the most important difference between the traditional Japanese and modern BJJ is in the training methods. Since samurai no longer fight on battlefields with full armour the preservation of the art has become paramount. There are 5 levels of training to make a martial art functionaland in my opinion Japanese Jiujitsu tends to focus on levels 1, 2 and maybe 3 solo training, partner training with low resistance, partner training with higher resistance.
Brazilian jiu-jitsu, by contrast, spends a TON of time in levels 4 and 5 contested situational sparring, and partner sparring with many techniquesand this pressure testing makes it possible to apply the techniques under very high levels of stress and pressure. And all this sparring makes BJJ a continually evolving martial art.
Does that mean that traditional Japanese Jiujitsu has nothing to offer BJJ or the modern martial artist? Traditional Japanese Jiujitsu evolved in a very different, and very violent, period of history. They reflect an environment in which almost everyone was armed, where you always had to worry about multiple opponents on the battlefield, and where every clash could potentially be a fight to the death.
The way the techniques are executed often reflect this different reality. For example, you might not do a technique in the most efficient way if using that particular method makes it difficult to disengage from your opponent. If you begin to understand these tradeoffs then you might just start thinking about your BJJ techniques in a different way, especially if you ever have to apply your skills in a self defense situation!
Therefore I would like to give you three additional resources to dive a little deeper into this subject…. In this episode of my podcast I do a deep dive into traditional Japanese Jiu-jitsu with my friend and black belt Alex Kask. This podcast episode, along with all my others, are available on my Strenuous Life Podcast, which you can subscribe to with a few easy clicks! Choose your audio player below and click on it to open up The Strenuous Life Podcast and from there, you can click to subscribe, or simply search for this episode which is episode Nothing beats some concrete examples for driving a point home.
Below are two videos I shot with Alex Kask, comparing and contrasting similar techniques performed in two different contexts. First, from my main Youtube channelis an example of how you might perform an armbar differently if you were worried that your opponent might pull a tanto and sever your femoral artery….
Martial Arts Styles: Judo vs. Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu (BJJ)
And here from my second, more self-defence oriented Youtube channelis an example of how you might apply the RNC or rear naked choke in a battlefield scenario where the BJJ approach of taking the back, getting your hooks in, and maintaining rear mount might get you killed…. Years ago Alex and I took a stab at comparing and contrasting submission grappling vs classical ju-jutsu. In that article we cover many of the same concepts, and then give a few more examples of how the techniques might be modified to fit the circumstances.
Check out that article on Grapplearts. The internet is a big place, and once you click away the odds of you ever coming back to this site are pretty small. To sign up just enter your best email below and look for the confirmation email with the download link for the book to land in your inbox within minutes! Search the Grapplearts website:. All rights reserved. Pin It on Pinterest.Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu and Judo are two of the most popular martial arts in existence.
There are hundreds of thousands of practitioners of these martial arts all around the world. However, to the novice eye — these two martial arts may seem alike. And this is not that far from the truth, to begin with.
There are many similarities between BJJ and Judo. This article will mention some of the similarities and differences between these two martial arts.
The most important thing that a BJJ practitioner can do is submit their opponent in the bout. BJJ bouts start with the two opponents standing up but the goal is to get to the ground. Most of the work in BJJ happens while the two players are on the ground. In BJJ, getting down to the ground is just the beginning of the match.
This aspect of the bout can culminate with the aforementioned submissions. The Judo matches start with the players standing up as well.Roger Gracie vs Buchecha - 2017 Gracie Pro Jiu-Jitsu
However, the main strategy in Judo is to grab your opponent as best as you can. Then you will give your best to destabilize him and make him unable to resist your techniques or counter them. After this, you will need to throw your opponent to the ground.
The similarity to BJJ here is that you can use these exact same set of moves to throw your opponent to the ground both in Judo and in BJJ. However, if you do this in Judo, then the match ends and you are the victor. If you do it in BJJ, then the match is just beginning and you only get some points. There is also a ground game aspect of Judo.
The Judokas will first try to throw their opponent to the ground.
If the throw is executed with solid technique — then the match ends. However, if there is sloppiness and the two Judokas fall to the ground — then one of them will need to submit the other. If the Judokas fail to do this, then the referee may stand them up again. So, in this sense, the critical point of focus for Judokas is the stand-up game where they get to try and throw their opponent to the ground.
But they also implement some ground game techniques such as chokes and armbars. The Gracies are known as pioneers of Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu. What the Gracies have done is set a challenge, inviting the top martial artists of the world to test their mettle against the Gracie family. The Gracies have won many of these matches by using the techniques of BJJ.
So, in essence, the culture of BJJ is that the practitioners will look for new challenges all the time and try to get the victory by any means. Judo is, in turn, a Japanese martial art. This is a martial art where there is a high level of focus placed on things that are beyond the martial art. It may be a bit of an oversimplification, but there is a saying that Judo is like fine wine while BJJ is like a beer.
The point is that both of these martial arts have their good sides and bad sides. The smartest thing in our opinion is to learn from both of these martial arts. You will get to learn many important things both from BJJ and from Judo as well.
If we were to simplify things — we will tell you the following — if you wish to improve your stand-up throwing game, then train Judo. If you wish to improve your ground game, then train BJJ. What remains now is for you to select which one of these martial arts will be your preferred choice. This is not obligatory, however — you can train both if you want to. But most people will have a drive towards one or the other.Judo vs BJJ.
Traditional Jujitsu Vs. Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu
Judo is a modern Olympic sport and a martial art that was developed in Japan by Jigoro Kano. It is very popular across the world and has caught the imagination of people as a self-defense system. Judo has been adopted in many cultures with minor variations and a system of self-defense called Brazilian JiuJitsu or simply BJJ in short got developed in Brazil.
To the uninitiated, and to casual observers, the two martial arts called judo and BJJ might look the same or at least strikingly similar. This is because of the fact that BJJ has been influenced a great deal by Judo, the Japanese martial art. In fact, it would be correct to call judo the progenitor of BJJ. However, despite similarities, there are enough differences between judo and BJJ that will be highlighted in this article.
Judo is both a modern Olympic sport as well as a martial art. It is a system of self-defense that focuses on grappling and throwing to overcome a heavier and armed opponent. Judo was developed by Jigoro Kano in as a new martial art from the earlier existing ancient Japanese martial art called Jujutsu. There is much less striking and thrusting in Judo than Jujutsu. The practitioners of judo are referred to as judokas. Judo caught the imagination of people across the world and soon became popular in many countries with minor variations and adaptations that are seen as local cultural influences.
BJJ refers to Brazilian Jiu Jitsu, a martial art that was a result of adaptation and modification of judo. Judoka Maeda taught Carlos Gracie the fundamentals of Kodokan judo. The knowledge was then passed on by Gracies to many more people after some modification, and they named the martial art as Brazilian Jiu Jitsu.
The basic premise of BJJ is that a weak individual can, with the help of the techniques in BJJ, hope to overcome a strong individual by fighting on the ground and using techniques such as chokeholds and joint locks. Brazilians could not distinguish between the ancient martial art called Jujutsu and the modern martial art called judo that was introduced by Kano in Japan. Coming from Engineering cum Human Resource Development background, has over 10 years experience in content developmet and management.
Leave a Reply Cancel reply.Every material arts lover out there probably knows something about Japanese jiu jitsu vs Brazilian jiu jitsu BJJ. So, what is the difference between jiu jitsu vs bjj? It was mainly used by the samurai soldiers in the battle field because it involved everything they needed to be successful when unarmed.
The art is still passed down from generation to generation to avoid it being watered down. The Grace family was particularly inspired by judo. Today, these grappling martial art styles are used in competitive sports across various disciplines.
The origin of jiu jitsu is still unresolved because it was discovered centuries ago. Some speculated that it originated from the Buddhist monks in India who wanted to defend themselves peacefully. It practices a lot of throws and locks which can be very dangerous. It is mostly self-defense oriented allowing you defeat an opponent faster. This art was mainly developed to be used by the samurai soldiers when unarmed in combat.
The original version had a combination of wrestling and other various bar-hundred techniques which includes to the use of leverage and friction instead of punches and kicks to defeat the opponent. This art uses submissions when hurting the opponent. In the s, judo, an art that effectively incorporates jiu jitsu was formed and became the official form of martial art used in Japanese combat. Nonetheless, jiu jitsu is not very effective when coming against a stronger and bigger opponent.
The Brazilian jiu jitsu was first introduced to Corlos Gracia Sr and his brother helio, by Mistyo maenad, both of these two brothers were not very impressive physically, particularly Helio Grecie who was weak and frail. This is the main reason why it focuses mainly on ground fighting aspects as opposed to judo which focuses on throws and sweeps.
On the ground it is very effective against an untrained opponent of any size. The BJJ is a much more of a relaxed art as it is less classical and includes less formality. While in the Japanese jiu jitsu and instructor dictates you, in the BJJ you get to test each and every move with the instructor. This competition uses kicks, knees, punches, elbows and submissions to subdue an opponent.
Helio, used BJJ to conquer a lot of good martial artists in Brazil and even challenged the Japanese Jiu jitsu champion who was 80 pounds heavier.
The modern BJJ is much more sports oriented losing some of its original self-defense aspects. First of the There is no term as perfect jiu jitsu but the advantages and points are what motivate the competitor to perfect their jiu-jistu. If you make a single mistake, you opponent will leapfrog you on the score board. For example, if a guard player uses the cockroach position while passively lying back and the top player passes the guard leading to an attach for submission, then the top player gets the advantages for being aggressive to the spectators memorization.
If the spectators are satisfied, it means more revenues and sponsorship. This also leads to opening of more jiu jitsu academies leading to a large talent pool to the satisfaction of everyone. Jiu jitsu fosters patience and discipline because of its timing and rhythm.
Excuting moves like throws and locks in the right moment can be effortless if done at the right time. This art of patience and self-discipline reduces stress. Also, jiu jitsu enhances you self-defense techniques because what you learn is also applicable in real life situations. Due to its rigorous from of training compared to other martial arts, jiu jitsu helps build you strength and endurance while increasing flexibility. On the cons side of jiu jitsu, the techniques involved can take time to perfect and use them effectively on the street.
Also, because its style is not meant for competition, if the rules of the completion are applied one could lose easily. The thinking of bjj goes beyond martial art of sport because it changes your life.Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu vs.
Which martial art is better?
BJJ vs Judo – Differences and Similarites
Hence, he removed some of the more dangerous jujutsu moves. By doing so, sparring, or newaza, became more popular. Judo was practiced in schools, as Kano had hoped. Helio's father, Gastao Gracie, helped a Kodokan Judo master named Mitsuyo Maeda at the time the terms judo and jujutsu were often used interchangeably with business in Brazil. In turn, Maeda taught Gastao's eldest son, Carlos, the art of judo.
Carlos taught the rest of his brothers what he had learned, including the smallest and frailest of them, Helio. Helio was often at a disadvantage when practicing the art because many of the moves in judo favored the stronger and larger fighter. Helio's art eventually became known as Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu. In addition, Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu teaches practitioners to effectively fight from one's back.
It is a patient art in which practitioners wait for openings and slowly move toward them in most cases. Despite similarities between the two arts on the ground, Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu uses leverage and patience more there. In that sense, it is widely and accurately believed to be a more complete grappling art.
But judo is the superior takedown style. Few arts compare to it in this way. Gracie agreed. This led to three Japanese judokas visiting Brazil. The trio was led by the champion of all Japanese champions, Masahiko Kimura. The other two fighters were Yamaguchi sixth-degree black belt and Yukio Kato fifth-degree black belt. The Japanese were reportedly afraid that if Gracie lost to Kimura, he would simply blame their weight differential.
Kato reportedly dominated the early goings, with Gracie taking the later stages of the fight. Kato then challenged Gracie to a rematch, which took place 23 days later at Pacaembu Gymnasium. Early on, the Japanese fighter threw Gracie hard. He also tried a choke with which Gracie had trouble. Before long, Gracie regained his strength and won the match, leaving Kato fell unconscious.
On Oct. Just about a month earlier, Gracie had defeated one of the best judo fighters in the world, Yukio Kato, by choke. Hence, there was a lot of pressure on Kimura, who had a to pound weight advantage on his smaller adversary. Kimura was widely considered to be the greatest judo fighter in the world, so the Japanese people were counting on him.We enjoyed our travels in the country so much and had such an outstanding experience with Nordic that we used them again this year to book a trip to visit part of the country that we didn't see last year.
We're already thinking of a return trip for next year--and will, of course, use Nordic again. We thoroughly appreciated and enjoyed our guide's knowledge and expertise. Brian was extremely informative, patient, and entertaining. He was very considerate of the fact that we were 2 active but older women. He was also very kind to other travellers who realized he was a guide and would stop him to ask advice.
Although this was to be my only trip to Scotland, thanks to his influence and fascinating instruction on the Highlands and Highlanders, I know I need to see more. I would let Nordic Visitor give more advice on the tour must sees. We met with the Edinburgh office staff - Maria, Anna, and Kris - after our tour was done, again Brian going above and beyond to bring us to meet them, days after our tour was over.
I cannot say enough good things about all the help they gave us. Even though we did not have the opportunity to meet with Helga in person we felt extremely well looked after by all her hard work and planning before and during the trip, and would completely recommend her and the Nordic Visitor team, you are all wonderful.
We would have loved to drop by the office to tell you in person how much fun we were having but we squeezed in extra activities so didn't end up having time to do so. We had asked for a tailored trip which was a day longer than the tour on the website, and Helga organised this effortlessly. We also requested a combination of comfort and superior rooms and again she organised this with no trouble.
The comfort rooms were pretty nice to stay in, occasionally having hot-tubs outside and always delicious food at their restaurants. The superior rooms we stayed at were incredibly memorable and really completed our honeymoon experience. It was the most fantastic honeymoon we could have imagined, thank you so much for organising it for us. We travelled as a family of two adults and one child and organised our combined tours 'Tale of Four cities' Scandinavian capitals and 'Iceland Full Circle' from afar totally online.
The online experience went extremely smoothly. Our consultant, Sirry, was very helpful and responsive.